nayanmaars
  • dear dhiwakar
    there are so many political and personal appointees in the original 63
    sundarar was one deserving candidate
    but his mother, father and foster father are also in the 63
    the pandyan royal family which welcomed sambanthar into madurai also
    joined the list(nedumaran, mangayarkarasi and their pm join the list)
    and in the process many deserving candidates got left out.
  • dear venkatesh sir,

    can u pls list out who were the undeserving and who were desreving yet left out????

    that wud throw a new perspective onnayanmars
  • Dear dhiwakar

    3 nayanmars come in sivakamiyin sabatham and another one is mentioned
    as a contemprory.

    who are they?
    venketesh.r
  • i remember appar peruman in SS... other is Siruthondar... that is
    paranjothi.. the third one mentioned is Thirugnana sambandar..... am
    i right???

    now there might be political influence in appt of siruthondar which
    too iam not sure.... but do you say that appt of appar and sambandar
    too as political or personal choices???

    Ennavo nadakkudhu.. marmamaa irukkudhu....
  • definitely appar and sambandar deserved their places.
    so did karaikal ammaiyar( the only sitting one if you noticed)
    so did a host of others.

    the two political apointees that you missed were charecters in ss

    narasimhas brother in law- the pandyan- nedumaran
    and the girl he loves mangayarkarasi.

    the personal apointees incluse sundarars mother and father.

    in that case those left out include appars sister who was
    responsible for his conversion.
    and kosengkat solans mother who on the day of her delivery hung
    upside down so that the delivery is delayed and the son is born a
    saiva devotee( according to the astrogers)
  • since i do not know much about her, might be iam missing the reason for she being appointed a nayanmar......

    but why do you say that nedumaran and Mangayarkarasiyar do not fit the bill???? can u elaborate ... i do not know about them anyway...

    the same regarding sundarar's father and mother..... if being the parents is the only criteria then we wud be having 126 nayanmars in parents alone assuming that only the original mother deserves to be in the list.... if you take the step mothers and all nobody knows how many it wil be.. ( enna sir panradhu.. budhdhi ippadi dhaan think pannudhu..) and another 63 i children.... so total 189 nayanmars......

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters