Vanakkam.....
  • Vanakkam,

    Nanbargale....

    I'm Prasath Babu from Bangalore...

    I read Kalki's Ponniyin Selvan from the PDF version
    available in "Project Madurai".This project is really
    nice and gives new life to all the ancient tamil
    works. I want to read other novels which are not fully
    available in E Text form. Can anybody tell me where
    can i bye or lend the other novels by Kalki in
    Bangalore? And i want to know about the novel
    "Udaiyar" by Balakumaran which tells the story
    starting from the place where Kalki has left in
    Ponniyin Selvan.

    I'm very much eager to read these novels. Plese reply
    me...


    Nanri.....

    R.Prasath Babu (Bangalore)
  • Hi babu

    the story of udayar starts somewhere 20 years(?) from where ponniyin
    selvan stops.( 3 years for sundara, 14 for uthama , and some for rrc)
    vikramans nandhi puraththu nayagi is a novel in the period after PS.
  • Dear Babu
    Welcome
    Venkat is absolutely right

    Nadhipura nayagi and Vandhiyadevanin vaal claim to be sequels to PS but honestly are a waste of time...Udayar again starts well but cannot even be mentioned in the leagues of PS
  • Hi Mr.Sridhar,

    Thank you for your reply.

    But i don't understand, whether u want me giveup
    reading nandhi puraththu nayagi? Is it not worth
    reading? In what sense? Is it not written so
    interestingly? Yesterday I went to the Book Festivel
    arranged in Palace Grounds in Bangalore, where i found
    Nandhipurathu nayagi, some people who were purchasing
    the same novel told me that it's good....
    I need some more clear views... please.

    I really admire Kalki. I support your point that very
    few authors can be viewed equal to Kalki. But written
    style does not matter for one who want to know the
    real history with some fiction.

    from
    Prasath Babu.
  • Dear Babu Prasath,
    Pls do not give up. Read. Compare with PS. Form opinion. Share with us
    when completed.
    anbudan / sps
  • Dear Babu
    I wouldnt say dont read it because if you read that you ll appreciate
    PS even more
    but the sad thing is the author almost distorts all the key players
    of PS with no progression in timeline

    Kundavai Vanathi are kind showed in bad light

    thats my personal opinion but read and pss your comments as SPS has
    said
  • Dear Dr. Sridhar,

    Sorry if I contradicted. Not intended. regards/ sps
  • Dear SPS
    enna vaarthai solringa...You are absolutely right each one has their preferences and might veiw it differently But to answer the Question would I have like NN better than PS had I read it forst no PS is still the best...like our Gokul said


    I owe you an apology in the first place I will meet Vija on the 6th of Dec and get BT.com sorted
    I might be(95%)in Madras in the second week of Feb Can we plan to meet and alsi have our first heritage quiz
  • DEAR SRI,
    MOST WELCOME. FEB FIRST WEEK.
    WE WILL MAKE THE MEET MEMORABLE.
    BEST REGARDS / SPS

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters