Ponniyin Selvan Varalaatru Peravai

The write up, is unfortunately , a diatribe , mixed with facts and fiction

VKR

Oh really? Maybe Einstein should have stuck with Germany instead of emigrating to USA. Following Gandhi’s request, he could have gone further ahead and laid down his life.

You are asking me to fall for the logical fallacy “Appeal to Authority”. So just because Einstein has few kind words for MKG, I should agree with MKG? Brilliance in one field does not necessarily transfer to brilliance (or understanding) in other fields.

http://jewishracism.blogspot.com/2007/12/how-einstein-helped-hitler.html

MKG asking the Jews to ‘voluntary suffering, even massacre’ is heights of stupidity, because being an extremist, he did not want to understand the other side. He supported the Khilafat Movement, only to be later on let down by the people he supported. It is fine for one individual to be naive and suffer betrayal and scorn. But expecting communities and nations to follow him is heights.

http://www.gandhiserve.org/information/writings_online/articles/gandhi_jews_palestine.html#%27The%20Jews%27,%20by%20Gandhi%20-%20From%20Harijan,%20November%2026,%201938

1. Netaji Subash Chandra Bose believed thatHitler’s Germany with allies
as Italy and Japan will give freedom to India and joined them.
What the British did not do in 100 years, the japanes did it in
just few months. The Jarawas of Nicobar and Andaman who even Tsunamis could not overawe were massacred by Japanese forces
which had arrived in the name of Subash. Was Subash who joined
the Hitler’s alliance Stupid ?????

2.Subramanya Bharathi and Rabindranath Tagore went into raptures
on Gandhi’s personality. Were they fools and Stupid to believe this
man ???

3. Ramana Mahrishi cried when Gandhiji died !!! He called the
Mahatma an incarnation of Rama Bhakt Hanuman. Was he stupid ???

4.Kanchi Paramacharya Chandrasekarendra Saraswathipraised Gandhiji in his Samanya Dharama
speech and told people to follow dharma which had raised Gandhi from
an ordinary person to a man without whom British were not ready to
discuss about Swarajya. Was he Stupid ?????

5.You talk about Khilafat. At that time Gandhiji was only one of the
tall leaders. What about other leaders who whole heartedly supported the movement. What about Lala Lajpat Rai, CR Das, Chintamani.
Were all these people fools and Stupid.

6.Krishna was let down by Yadavas. Was he stupid.

If all of these people are stupids , then Gandhiji is in elite Company dear.

I ask for the members not issue provocative statements
like Shivaji was looter and Gandhiji was stupid.
Such Statements if issued, will be contested.

Regards.
S.Karthik
Vandemataram