Mystery Novel
  • saamingalaa....

    We are talking about PS as one of the Great novels where Mystery prevails till the last and nobody cud guess who killed AK...

    Aana if you read "Justice Jagannathan " by "Devan"... you wud realise that PS is no mystery at all.....

    rendu naal kidaicha leavela andha kadhaiya padichchen.... semma kadhai.... kadaisi varaikkum yaaru kolaikaarannu kandu pudikkave mudiyaadhu.....

    "Justice jagannathan " kitta PS pichchai vaanganum......
  • a a kaaa thiruppi vEthaalam murunga maram eridichchu

    (3 naal leave la puththunarchi petru vantha veethaalm.)

    yow dhiwaker

    ponniyin selvan is not a mystery novel.
    mystery and suspense is just a part of it.
    kalki's greatest achievement was humanising the historical charecters


    aadityans murder is a real historical mystery.
    kalki was magnanimous enough not to pin the blame on anybody.
    just gave us a list of charecters to choose from.

    devan is good i agree. but literature of two people is something that
    we cannot really compare
  • thalaivare...

    historical characters were also human.... so where did the point of humanising them come ???? edho oru boodhathaiyo peiyayyo avar humanise pannirundhaa .. alladhu edhaavadhu oru mirugathai humanise pannirundhaa othukkalaam.....

    kalki was magnanimous and all is summaa..... avarukku kadhaiya eppadi mudikaradhunnu theriyalai..... kaaranam engeyo aaramichchu engeyo eduthukinu ponaar.. he himself lost the thread.....

    so thaan potta mudichai avukka theriyaama edho mystery adhu idhunnu samaalichachhu.....

    and saying that Kalki cannot be compared and all is just Kanmoodithanamaana abhimaanam....

    Justice Jagannathan anyday is better than PS as Murder Mystery.....

    Devanoda ezhuthai paakanume.... mavane pinni edukkaraar..... Indian Penal code, Criminal Procedure Code, Evidence Act .. nnu ellaa sattathayum summa oru vazhi panraar.....adhellaam mathavangalukku suttu pottaalum varaadhu.....
  • kilambittaangaiyaa...
    kilambittanga.
  • vanakkam,

    annen dhiwakar annen, namakku neram sariyilla annen!

    Humanise-na inga literally manithahanmai illai. engeyo history book-
    la padichcavangalai namma kooda ulaava vittare, athai solrom!

    avar kadhaiyai mudikka mudiyamal thinariyathu ennamo unmai than.
    athe samayam, he played it safe. KAN & Sathasiva Pandaraththar
    differed on Uththama. appadi irukkum pothu, 'namakku en vambu' endru
    than kalki othungi irukka vendum.

    avar mystery ezhutha mudiyama samalichchu, sodhappinatha enakku
    thonalai. I guess he did it purposefully. kalvettilaiye, 'irul
    soozhnthathu, kali'-nu mottaiya than irukku. So, Kalki also made it
    enigmatic, as in history!

    Pls don't view PS as a murder mystery.

    swetha
  • akka... swetha akka.... echcharikkaikku nanri akka!!!!

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters